top of page

How the Landmark Missouri Price-Fixing Case and are changing the game in real estate

In a landmark decision on October 31, a Kansas City, Missouri, jury found the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and several major residential brokerages guilty of illegal price-fixing, potentially changing the future of real estate commissions.

This ruling, which may result in over $5 billion in damages to Missouri home sellers, challenges the longstanding industry standard of 5% to 6% commission rates.

The plaintiffs in this case contested the requirement that sellers must offer compensation to buyer agents to list homes on local multiple listing services. This practice, they argued, facilitated collusion among agents and brokers to maintain inflated commission rates. Historically, the industry used explicit price schedules in the 1940s, but shifted to collusion after challenges from the Justice Department. This case raises critical questions about the justification of high commission rates, often uniform regardless of an agent's experience or the effort required for a particular sale.

The Kansas City ruling, along with a similar case in Chicago set for trial next year, suggests a future where commission rates are no longer tied together. This shift could lead to more competition and potentially lower commission rates, benefiting consumers. The Consumer Federation of America anticipates a decrease in average rates from 5-6% to 3-4%, with significant savings for home sellers.

This case also challenges the notion that buyer agent commissions are a necessary cost baked into home prices. Instead, it opens up possibilities for rate negotiation and comparison shopping, ultimately lowering the cost of buying a home. This movement towards price competition over price-setting could revolutionize the real estate brokerage market, aligning it more closely with other competitive markets and benefiting consumers.

In light of these developments, services like become even more valuable for real estate needs. These platforms offer an alternative to traditional commission models, providing cost-effective solutions that align with the evolving landscape of the real estate market. As the industry transitions from fixed prices to competitive rates, such services offer an innovative and consumer-friendly approach to buying and selling homes.

8 views0 comments


bottom of page